News Ticker

Could This Be The End To Facebook: Facebook Faces Suit Over Private Messages

According to LinkedIn Member, Bernard Marr:

Facebook, the popular social network with over a billion users world wide, has just been hit with a class-action lawsuit. The allegations, revealed in the FT, are that Facebook systematically scans the content of private messages so it can sell the data to third parties such as advertisers.

Facebook’s entire business model is based on the fact that it monitors what users write, like and up-load in order to sell this information on to others. I have covered some of the concerns about this in my articles ‘How Facebook Exploits Your Private Information’ and ‘How Facebook Likes Reveal Your Intimate Secrets’. In principle, there is nothing wrong with Facebook using our data to make commercial gains. In the end, the service is free and Facebook has to make money somehow. However, my biggest concern is that the data mining activities are not as transparent as they should be.

Facebook has been criticized for this lack of transparency on many occasions, but two Facebook users now believe Facebook has gone too far. Users Matthew Campbell from Arkansas and Michael Hurley from Oregon have filed a class-action lawsuit on behalf of the over 166m Facebook users in the US. The accusation is that Facebook is violating the Electronic Communications Privacy Act by scanning and exploiting the content of private messages sent via the Facebook platform without prior consent by users.


The issue here is that ‘private’ messages are seen by most users as exactly that: private! The accusation is that Facebook identifies website links (URLs) contained in private messages and then searches these websites in order to profile users. In their accusation Campbell and Hurley argue: “Representing to users that the content of Facebook messages is ‘private’ creates an especially profitable opportunity for Facebook, because users who believe they are communicating on a service free from surveillance are likely to reveal facts about themselves that they would not reveal had they known the content was being monitored.”

A Facebook spokesperson told Bloomberg that the allegations are without merit and that Facebook will defend itself vigorously. Of course they would say that. The trouble for Facebook is to strike the right balance between offering a customer service in form of a free social networking platform and shareholder returns, especially profits from selling data and advertising.

To answer my own question from the headline: No, I don’t think that this lawsuit will be the end of Facebook. However, I do feel very strongly about the need for better transparency about how our data is used and believe it can lead to a loss of trust that could seriously threaten companies like Facebook. To me, it feels like Facebook (as well as many other companies including Google, Yahoo! etc.) are trying to hide the data mining and analytics activities in their very long Terms and Conditions, to which most people sign up but rarely fully read or understand. Maybe a simple opt out with an alternative “paid for” service would be a good option.

What do you think? What is your view on Facebook exploiting your private data? Would you consider a “paid for” service if your privacy was guaranteed?

About Qui Talks (1248 Articles)
Qui Talks is your online entertainment and lifestyle media outlet. There is some much going on the world of everything entertainment and Qui Talks covers everything you need to know. Qui Talks not only provides the latest in celebrity news, but also features webisodes of advice, fitness tips, and life empowerment. The red carpet no longer belongs to the glamour dolls because it’s being taken over by Qui Talks. New York is full of high life energy with celebrity events, premiere parties and live fashion shows- Qui Talks is always at the center of the action to make sure you’re in the mix too, with the finest coverage of New York City’s top notch events, places to be and styles to wear. Qui Talks reaches out to thousands daily with news from all over the country and worldwide. From the President’s visit to Selma all the way to the many celebrities visiting the western hemisphere’s hidden gem- Haiti, Qui Talks has exclusive photos of it all. Here’s to the woman bringing you the juice; Qui Joacin. Starting out as a fashion power house at just 16, Qui always had a creative eye and the drive to take charge. It was in 2011 after her first reporting gig that Qui decided she wanted to incorporate her love for style and merge with delivering the freshest news, thus the inception of Qui TV. Miss Joacin created Qui Talks from her passion in media but also to inspire all young minds that what they truly aspire to be is within themselves to unleash. Perspective is everything and Qui Talks does just that; shines a new light on the very topics in conversations around the watercooler or in line at Starbucks. Qui Talks is online media’s new major pit stop. Weekly updates and daily posts will make sure that viewers are never out of the loop. Forward thinking mixed with New York style will have you hooked on what Qui Talks is going to deliver next.

Talkers Tell Me What You Think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: